Originally posted by george w
View Post
DTWC--Illegal parts
Collapse
X
-
You're missing the point. Lead is still allowed on the car just not on the axle tube. What if the lead the fell off and hit Francis wasn't axle tube lead and they assumed it was. The problem was never solved and therefore is a knee jerk reaction. Unless the ban all forms off mounted ballast eliminating axle tube ballast is not going to stop lead from falling off when people attach it improperly. Believe me I've seen plenty of scary ways lead is mounted to a car. The proper response would have been to mandate how all ballast is mounted to the car. Good clamps, 2- 1/2" bolts, no all thread, etc.
-
The proper response has been in the rule book for years on how to properly place lead on a car look for yourself, lead on a axletube or really on any fourlink bar is unsafe for the drivers let alone the thousands of fans in the stands. How many times have you looked a car over after a violent crash? Seen any bent, broke fourlink bars? Whether it was at the hiem or dead center of the bar itself it doesnt need a 50# weight on it period its just asking for trouble. Since your asumming I've never hung lead how many times you nut an bolted a car an stumbled across a cracked axletube from the night before simply from a rough track? Sooner or later the lead will be bolted an have a cable attatched sadly it'll prolly take another accident for it to happen, but when it does i bet you'll see other series sactions an tracks follow suit.Last edited by george w; 10-17-2016, 06:29 PM.
Comment
-
I don't think anyone is mounting lead to a 4-link bar, much less a 50lb piece....that's not really possible. Have you ever saw a brake caliper get knocked off.....then why would a piece of lead mounted in the same place, get knocked off?Originally posted by george w View PostThe proper response has been in the rule book for years on how to properly place lead on a car, look for yourself. An for the record I'm fine with it above the axle tube but below the axletube or really on any fourlink bar is unsafe for the drivers let alone the thousands of fans in the stands. How many times have you looked a car over after a violent crash? Seen any bent, broke fourlink bars? Whether it was at the hiem or dead center of the bar itself it doesnt need a 50# weight on it period its just asking for trouble. Sooner or later the lead will be bolted an have a cable attatched sadly it'll prolly take another accident for it to happen, but when it does i bet you'll see other series sactions an tracks follow suit.
It was a knee-jerk reaction!Turn LEFT, Vote RIGHT!
Comment
-
Are you talking about the ones that have the braided steel lines attatched to them and are bolted on aswell thanks for proving my point above .....the series made your alls so called knee jerk reaction I'm simply backing there decision is all.Last edited by george w; 10-17-2016, 06:37 PM.
Comment
-
They know it WAS "axle tube lead" and they addressed it specifically the next night at the Diamond Nationals during the drivers meeting. It was immediately banned from being mounted to the axle tube (anyone with common sense should know not to mount it there anyway).Originally posted by manwplan View PostYou're missing the point. Lead is still allowed on the car just not on the axle tube. What if the lead the fell off and hit Francis wasn't axle tube lead and they assumed it was. The problem was never solved and therefore is a knee jerk reaction. Unless the ban all forms off mounted ballast eliminating axle tube ballast is not going to stop lead from falling off when people attach it improperly. Believe me I've seen plenty of scary ways lead is mounted to a car. The proper response would have been to mandate how all ballast is mounted to the car. Good clamps, 2- 1/2" bolts, no all thread, etc.
Comment
-
-
This is comical! No one has a problem with a brake caliper, bolted to the rearend, with a rotor spinning through it at high rpms, but they have a problem with a piece of lead bolted to the same bracket with 2 bolts, and nothing spinning inside it! SMHTurn LEFT, Vote RIGHT!
Comment
-
I don't normally join into these, but what exactly is "comical"??
You are comparing apples and oranges.
A standard billet brake caliper weighs about 4lbs. Its mounted with 2 grade 5-8 bolts to a billet bracket that is also attached w/ above hardware along w/ being drilled and tapped into the tube itself. It is also tethered by a stainless steel brake line....all of which is done because that is what the design requires.
Lead, weighing between 20-60lbs, can and more importantly IS mounted in some absolutely absurd ways. As posted previously, the "Mounting of Ballast(Lead)" is addressed in EVERY rulebook I've ever seen for ANY class, let alone a national late model series. "ie painted white w/ car# mounted with minimum 2- 3/8" grade 5-8 bolts per 25#"
However, racers, as a generalization will take great liberties and shortcuts when given enough leeway...I've actually seen w/ my own eyes a guy in one of the stock classes mount lead with duct/racer tape...AND ONLY TAPE.
The idea/rule/ruling in this matter, if not for anything else, is to protect the racer from himself, and ultimately his fellow racers, track workers, officials etc. IMO
Comment
-
The only time I have had lead come off is when we bought some grade 8 all thread.We had been using standard all thread from Lowes with no problems.The first piece broke off when the car was just sitting it the shop,Second piece was 20lbs mounted under the drivers feet.Went back to cheap stuff and never broke one again.
Comment
-
Very well said. Whole post, spot on.Originally posted by dtlm5 View PostI don't normally join into these, but what exactly is "comical"??
You are comparing apples and oranges.
A standard billet brake caliper weighs about 4lbs. Its mounted with 2 grade 5-8 bolts to a billet bracket that is also attached w/ above hardware along w/ being drilled and tapped into the tube itself. It is also tethered by a stainless steel brake line....all of which is done because that is what the design requires.
Lead, weighing between 20-60lbs, can and more importantly IS mounted in some absolutely absurd ways. As posted previously, the "Mounting of Ballast(Lead)" is addressed in EVERY rulebook I've ever seen for ANY class, let alone a national late model series. "ie painted white w/ car# mounted with minimum 2- 3/8" grade 5-8 bolts per 25#"
However, racers, as a generalization will take great liberties and shortcuts when given enough leeway...I've actually seen w/ my own eyes a guy in one of the stock classes mount lead with duct/racer tape...AND ONLY TAPE.
The idea/rule/ruling in this matter, if not for anything else, is to protect the racer from himself, and ultimately his fellow racers, track workers, officials etc. IMOUp in the air who my next “favorite†driver is. Really losing hope on Bloomer getting anywhere back to “normalâ€.
Comment
-
As a a owner/driver for 6 decades I can't even begin to count the number of things I've been smacked by that have come off of cars from brake parts to piston chunks to body parts. Two weeks ago I caught half a heim joint in the helmet (brand new) through the screened bars in front of my face. Luckily my eyes and teeth are still in my head but countless face shields, a few helmets and several cuts and bruises later I've reached the conclusion that, many times, the flying parts are more dangerous than the actual racing. You can't do much about broken parts but fastening everything properly, especially lead, is a must.
Comment
-
I am not convinced of that. Lead was removed from the racing surface before Steve's incident. As far as post incident, I think there would have been way more helmet damage and a dead Francis had he been hit with lead.Originally posted by fryefan View PostThey know it WAS "axle tube lead" and they addressed it specifically the next night at the Diamond Nationals during the drivers meeting. It was immediately banned from being mounted to the axle tube (anyone with common sense should know not to mount it there anyway).Modern Day Spec Wedge Racing
Comment
-
[QUOTE=dtlm5;2053940]I don't normally join into these, but what exactly is "comical"??
You are comparing apples and oranges.
A standard billet brake caliper weighs about 4lbs. Its mounted with 2 grade 5-8 bolts to a billet bracket that is also attached w/ above hardware along w/ being drilled and tapped into the tube itself. It is also tethered by a stainless steel brake line....all of which is done because that is what the design requires.
So as I stated, a piece of lead should be mounted on the same billet bracket with the same size bolts....or did I miss something?Turn LEFT, Vote RIGHT!
Comment
-
Mounted properly, yes. And a tire can kick up a lot of sh!t. A 20lb piece of lead or so, I'd say no, but a smaller one, yeah.Originally posted by Jim11h View PostSiding with M-B.....throw a chunk of lead once. What's odds a tire gonna pick up lead and throw it? Mounted properly it ain't going anywhere. I would think though would stress tubes in an incorrect wayUp in the air who my next “favorite†driver is. Really losing hope on Bloomer getting anywhere back to “normalâ€.
Comment
Comment