Originally posted by Clayton_Wetter
View Post
Bloomquist lawsuit???
Collapse
X
-
And he may well have had his owns scales checked out too, before making ANY claims. Makes total sense.Originally posted by cutman View PostWhat are they basing their weight off of before heading to the track? Why did Bloomer say he weighed the car when returning to the shop and it made weight? Maybe his scales were off.
Comment
-
a quick comment on a couple of recent intelligent posts:
LM14: I completely agree with everything you've posted on this thread. been attending races since the late '60's. and what you stated is exactly the way it's always been done. I actually witnessed a promoter's son get DQ'ed at the scales for being 10 lbs. light. no argument. no whine. no favoritism.
but...
"just dust" made the perfect counter-point compared to all the other crap we've read through: "When you start
taking things to a court of law , and you are using scales for the outcome of a event , that the prize will be money , and the result of the rules say you must qualify by weight and other measures , then all that becomes relevant in court ."
right or wrong, weights and measures, tire testing, or anything else that is challenged in the courts...
well, let's just say that "we've always done things this way" isn't the answer. especially when a judge/jury has no interest/background in the topics being argued.
personally, I believe Bloomquist was light at the scale (no one that was subject to weighing complained) and all 5 drivers suspended for tire treatment were racing on cheated tires, regardless of if they were aware of it (who of the five would have full control of their equipment?).
there is another mega-poster on this forum that has made many posts concerning the validity of the tire testing process while at the same time hoping for clarity in the future.
while I tend to disagree with the poster's overall conclusion of innocence in these most recent DQ's (especially given the history of those found in violation, along with my regulatory background, that included lab testing as a basis for fines and suspensions), what I can't disagree with is the hope that the entire process is clarified and simplified.
the devil on my shoulder wants me to say one more thing: WoO/Bloomer/tire issues go back to at least 2009. but i'm sure all of that is forgiven/forgotten.
JMO.Last edited by klemmabyna; 11-03-2016, 07:23 PM.And the days that I keep my gratitude higher than my expectations, well, I have really good days - Ray Wylie Hubbard
Comment
-
There just has to be a limit to your posting on threads. You made your point the first post, all the rest is wasting everyone's time, including your own!!!Originally posted by perverton View PostI would think he did if he made the feature you have go across the scales after the heat ,dispute that bloomer fans
Now go pop your nose zit again!!!!
Comment
-
Something else to think about was the year that Babb won the big show , and he was even closer to making weight than Scott was.. the thing that made him light at the scales was the engine swap before the feature. So with that being said you better know what your engines weight and keep that in mind if you ever get yourself in that position..
Comment
-
Truck scales are a totally different beast. That is driven by maximum weight on each axle based on the axle spacing of the truck and overall weight. Those weights are set forth by the Federal Highway Department and they set the standards for these measurements. Those standards set the accuracy (how close the scale weighs a known weight) and the tolerance of the scales (how small of a weight the scale must weigh). That's why truck scales are certified even though they may not be used for pay (weigh boys along the interstate) or are used for pay (rock quarry). The Federal Highway Department sets those standards for trucks so everything is equal across the country for those hauling.
All of the rules I've raced under clearly stated that the track scales were the controlling scale. Either by sanction, speech at a drivers meeting or general track rules. Most times we were 5 to 10# different than what we weighed at home. Sometimes we were 25# off. In my experience, most track scales are poorly cared for, not cleaned, not lubricated and not level. I never trusted a track scale so I always had my driver cross the scales before hot laps so we knew where we were.
As far as court, anything goes. You can sue for anything at any time. Get a jury of people that know nothing about scale rules and laws and it becomes the lawyers job to educate them. I've been the defendant (representing my employer) in construction cases that involved weights and measures, who had contract/property control and wrongful death suits. Never lost a case because our lawyer educated himself on the specific issue and then educated the jury. We had proper representation. I do have court experience and have spent time being deposed and been a prime witness that spent a day on the stand. It's a lot of fun (not!).
Guess everyone on here will just need to sit back and wait for an outcome. We don't have a real stake in any of it. I never had a car kicked out for being too light. I've been warned we flirting with it but never DQ for that.
I have also been on the other side of the coin. I am now part of a promotional group. My personal scales have been the track scales this year. When I set them up, I weigh myself on each one and see that it comes out exactly the same. I also know from racing against guys for years who runs heavy, who pushes the limits. I ask a few heavy guys that cross the scales how compare to what they were at home. No complaints so far. We did DQ a car for 5# and he didn't complain. He admitted he was pushing it pretty close. Wasn't for a lot of money but it was still a DQ.
Racers are generally well informed to what their cars are doing weight wise. The exception to that would be losing a weight while racing. At that point it becomes a non issue since they will be DQ for losing the weight most likely.
Some of you people need to get out from behind a keyboard and actually build a race car, maintain and set up a race car, work at a track, be an official, get some real experience at this stuff. It's a lot more interesting if you actually do it.
JMO,
SParkLast edited by LM14; 11-04-2016, 02:10 AM.
Comment
-
great post except a lawsuit like this in hand can cripple the racing industry , which some say its not doing real good at this time with low car counts and low crowds , all I will say be careful what you ask forOriginally posted by LM14 View PostTruck scales are a totally different beast. That is driven by maximum weight on each axle based on the axle spacing of the truck and overall weight. Those weights are set forth by the Federal Highway Department and they set the standards for these measurements. Those standards set the accuracy (how close the scale weighs a known weight) and the tolerance of the scales (how small of a weight the scale must weigh). That's why truck scales are certified even though they may not be used for pay (weigh boys along the interstate) or are used for pay (rock quarry). The Federal Highway Department sets those standards for trucks so everything is equal across the country for those hauling. All of the rules I've raced under clearly stated that the track scales were the controlling scale. Either by sanction, speech at a drivers meeting or general track rules. Most times we were 5 to 10# different than what we weighed at home. Sometimes we were 25# off. In my experience, most track scales are poorly cared for, not cleaned, not lubricated and not level. I never trusted a track scale so I always had my driver cross the scales before hot laps so we knew where we were. As far as court, anything goes. You can sue for anything at any time. Get a jury of people that know nothing about scale rules and laws and it becomes the lawyers job to educate them. I've been the defendant (representing my employer) in construction cases that involved weights and measures, who had contract/property control and wrongful death suits. Never lost a case because our lawyer educated himself on the specific issue and then educated the jury. We had proper representation. I do have court experience and have spent time being deposed and been a prime witness that spent a day on the stand. It's a lot of fun (not!). Guess everyone on here will just need to sit back and wait for an outcome. We don't have a real stake in any of it. I never had a car kicked out for being too light. I've been warned we flirting with it but never DQ for that. I have also been on the other side of the coin. I am now part of a promotional group. My personal scales have been the track scales this year. When I set them up, I weigh myself on each one and see that it comes out exactly the same. I also know from racing against guys for years who runs heavy, who pushes the limits. I ask a few heavy guys that cross the scales how compare to what they were at home. No complaints so far. We did DQ a car for 5# and he didn't complain. He admitted he was pushing it pretty close. Wasn't for a lot of money but it was still a DQ. Racers are generally well informed to what their cars are doing weight wise. The exception to that would be losing a weight while racing. At that point it becomes a non issue since they will be DQ for losing the weight most likely. Some of you people need to get out from behind a keyboard and actually build a race car, maintain and set up a race car, work at a track, be an official, get some real experience at this stuff. It's a lot more interesting if you actually do it. JMO, SPark
Comment
-
Whatever the outcome of the lawsuit........things are getting looked at differently, big time promoters realize this can happen,and are tightening up their programs.
Tires are being looked at differently and whether anyone wants to admit it I bet scales at tracks are being checked a little more by the owners and series to ensure its a non issue going forward etc......bottom line, it's a great wake up call for the sport.
I don't think the suit has a chance in hell, but the sport is better today because of it......IMO.Where is the move over flag when you need it?????
Comment
Comment