Originally posted by MasterSbilt_Racer
View Post
Tiregate?
Collapse
X
-
Honestly, I'm not sure Hoosier owes anyone anything. And I'm not a fan of their tactics. They should give guidance to the sanctions about batch tolerances, but it's up to the jury to tell us what they call a fail.Originally posted by ZERO25 View PostYep......a little openness and honesty from the sanction bodies and Hoosier would go a long way in this tire testing fiasco!Modern Day Spec Wedge Racing
Comment
-
I can 100% tell you that if it doesn't appear as the benchmark then it doesn't meet the benchmark and is called such. There are not "tolerances" set as you guys seem to suggest. It either conforms to the benchmark or it doesn't. They don't say it has 100 ppm of sea salt in it. They say it does not conform to the benchmark provided by the manufacturer. Blue Ridge has been testing racing tires and fuel for many years. Those that question them may not understand how science works or need someone to blame. Blue Ridge is bonded and licensed with over 25 years in the business. They have ZERO reason to screw anyone. The sanctions have ZERO reason to screw anyone. It pisses me off that anyone tries to point it at sanctions. I have a VERY specific process to collect samples. It is akin to a forensic process that maintains a chain of custody. The process for my events is: Tire is marked at scale. Official follows competitor to their hauler. Official instructs crew member which tire to use. Official collects date code and affixes this to the evidence bag along with the compound of the tire and sample name. The official then opens a new glass vial. The official instructs the crew member, using his own grooving iron, to remove a sample from the outer tread block of the tire and then rotate 1/3 of a turn. Then remove a sample from the middle of the tire and rotate another 1/3 of a turn and remove a sample from the inside of the tire. Each sample is placed by the crew member into the open vial that the official is holding as it is removed. Once all samples are in the vial the top is screwed on and then it is sealed with a decal. The vial is then placed inside of the evidence bag and it is sealed. The crew member then signs on the bag along with the official agreeing it is sealed. The team is given a "receipt tab" which is attached to the bag. It has the unique number of the bag on it. When the sample arrives Blue Ridge confirms integrity of the bag and the sample as unopened and intact. Sample is then run. At no point does any official even touch the samples. So I have no idea how anyone can question the integrity of the sample. It is sealed in a tamperproof evidence bag inside a glass vial. It is no secret and I don't mind sharing it. People want transparency but when you give it to them they don't believe it.
Comment
-
You missed the part where their past results have shown that 62-76% of the original ingredients of the tire don't exist anymore? How would that tire even be useable if that's the case? It was mentioned that Blue Ridge doesnt make the call. That is correct. The call is made by the sanctioning body. But it was also mentioned that the benchmarks they go by are not made public. I will tell you why they are not public. I had already mentioned that there is always a 40% chance that the benchmark may have never been right when the tire was created. The benchmarks should change each time there is a brand new batch of tires made; but that does not happen. So there is the opportunity for the original benchmark to get way out of whack before it reels itself back in to the guidelines the company says they follow when manufacturing these tires. Like I stated before if blue ridge looks bad it's only because what they have to work with is already flawed. I'm gonna fry for this but Hoosier knows why this happens and they dont care. They hold a monopoly on the market and they know it. Nobody will challenge them because Hoosier would stop putting in all that sponsorship money. Have you noticed in the last 2 years in just dirt late model racing alone, how many races have had dozens of cars with tire issues? Straight from 2 prominent Hoosier dealers ... "Trust us. They have changed the way they make these tires. And it's not for the better either. It's all about the money!"Originally posted by flagone View PostI can 100% tell you that if it doesn't appear as the benchmark then it doesn't meet the benchmark and is called such. There are not "tolerances" set as you guys seem to suggest. It either conforms to the benchmark or it doesn't. They don't say it has 100 ppm of sea salt in it. They say it does not conform to the benchmark provided by the manufacturer. Blue Ridge has been testing racing tires and fuel for many years. Those that question them may not understand how science works or need someone to blame. Blue Ridge is bonded and licensed with over 25 years in the business. They have ZERO reason to screw anyone. The sanctions have ZERO reason to screw anyone. It pisses me off that anyone tries to point it at sanctions. I have a VERY specific process to collect samples. It is akin to a forensic process that maintains a chain of custody. The process for my events is: Tire is marked at scale. Official follows competitor to their hauler. Official instructs crew member which tire to use. Official collects date code and affixes this to the evidence bag along with the compound of the tire and sample name. The official then opens a new glass vial. The official instructs the crew member, using his own grooving iron, to remove a sample from the outer tread block of the tire and then rotate 1/3 of a turn. Then remove a sample from the middle of the tire and rotate another 1/3 of a turn and remove a sample from the inside of the tire. Each sample is placed by the crew member into the open vial that the official is holding as it is removed. Once all samples are in the vial the top is screwed on and then it is sealed with a decal. The vial is then placed inside of the evidence bag and it is sealed. The crew member then signs on the bag along with the official agreeing it is sealed. The team is given a "receipt tab" which is attached to the bag. It has the unique number of the bag on it. When the sample arrives Blue Ridge confirms integrity of the bag and the sample as unopened and intact. Sample is then run. At no point does any official even touch the samples. So I have no idea how anyone can question the integrity of the sample. It is sealed in a tamperproof evidence bag inside a glass vial. It is no secret and I don't mind sharing it. People want transparency but when you give it to them they don't believe it.
Comment
-
So where's the secured back up sample to verify the validity of the original secured sample?
I perform drug and alcohol testing on a regular basis and there are always two samples sent to the lab when my original sample from a test subject came up non-negative from my onsite test
This tire testing deal will eventually blow up in the labs and sanctions faces when someone with a pocket full of money takes them to task and starts a civil action against them.
Why do they refuse to publish the list of "chemicals" being found that don't conform to the "benchmark".
Not a (not a nice word)(not a nice word)(not a nice word)(not a nice word) thing proprietary to those....
Comment
-
My question on the chain of custody and benchmarks come before you guys even see the tire.Originally posted by flagone View PostI can 100% tell you that if it doesn't appear as the benchmark then it doesn't meet the benchmark and is called such. There are not "tolerances" set as you guys seem to suggest. It either conforms to the benchmark or it doesn't. They don't say it has 100 ppm of sea salt in it. They say it does not conform to the benchmark provided by the manufacturer. Blue Ridge has been testing racing tires and fuel for many years. Those that question them may not understand how science works or need someone to blame. Blue Ridge is bonded and licensed with over 25 years in the business. They have ZERO reason to screw anyone. The sanctions have ZERO reason to screw anyone. It pisses me off that anyone tries to point it at sanctions. I have a VERY specific process to collect samples. It is akin to a forensic process that maintains a chain of custody. The process for my events is: Tire is marked at scale. Official follows competitor to their hauler. Official instructs crew member which tire to use. Official collects date code and affixes this to the evidence bag along with the compound of the tire and sample name. The official then opens a new glass vial. The official instructs the crew member, using his own grooving iron, to remove a sample from the outer tread block of the tire and then rotate 1/3 of a turn. Then remove a sample from the middle of the tire and rotate another 1/3 of a turn and remove a sample from the inside of the tire. Each sample is placed by the crew member into the open vial that the official is holding as it is removed. Once all samples are in the vial the top is screwed on and then it is sealed with a decal. The vial is then placed inside of the evidence bag and it is sealed. The crew member then signs on the bag along with the official agreeing it is sealed. The team is given a "receipt tab" which is attached to the bag. It has the unique number of the bag on it. When the sample arrives Blue Ridge confirms integrity of the bag and the sample as unopened and intact. Sample is then run. At no point does any official even touch the samples. So I have no idea how anyone can question the integrity of the sample. It is sealed in a tamperproof evidence bag inside a glass vial. It is no secret and I don't mind sharing it. People want transparency but when you give it to them they don't believe it.Where is the move over flag when you need it?????
Comment
-
I've always heard they won't release what they found because it gives the juice makers better data to produce better juice........talk about conspiracy theories.Originally posted by ClampedUp View PostSo where's the secured back up sample to verify the validity of the original secured sample?
I perform drug and alcohol testing on a regular basis and there are always two samples sent to the lab when my original sample from a test subject came up non-negative from my onsite test
This tire testing deal will eventually blow up in the labs and sanctions faces when someone with a pocket full of money takes them to task and starts a civil action against them.
Why do they refuse to publish the list of "chemicals" being found that don't conform to the "benchmark".
Not a (not a nice word)(not a nice word)(not a nice word)(not a nice word) thing proprietary to those....Where is the move over flag when you need it?????
Comment
-
LOL Well you definitely have the number one reason why they don't release the data. Number 2 is because they know that the tests are not accurate due to a few reasons, and three, people would really point the finger at Hoosier if they had ALL the info, and the sanctioning bodies won't let that happen.Originally posted by Barbecueboy View PostI've always heard they won't release what they found because it gives the juice makers better data to produce better juice........talk about conspiracy theories.
Comment
-
Someone, somewhere, some time, gave the lab criteria for what does or doesn't meet the benchmark. No lab I have ever been involved in, does the testing and sets the pass/fail criteria. Testing has been most of my life.Originally posted by flagone View PostI can 100% tell you that if it doesn't appear as the benchmark then it doesn't meet the benchmark and is called such. There are not "tolerances" set as you guys seem to suggest. It either conforms to the benchmark or it doesn't. They don't say it has 100 ppm of sea salt in it. They say it does not conform to the benchmark provided by the manufacturer. Blue Ridge has been testing racing tires and fuel for many years. Those that question them may not understand how science works or need someone to blame. Blue Ridge is bonded and licensed with over 25 years in the business. They have ZERO reason to screw anyone. The sanctions have ZERO reason to screw anyone. It pisses me off that anyone tries to point it at sanctions. I have a VERY specific process to collect samples. It is akin to a forensic process that maintains a chain of custody. The process for my events is: Tire is marked at scale. Official follows competitor to their hauler. Official instructs crew member which tire to use. Official collects date code and affixes this to the evidence bag along with the compound of the tire and sample name. The official then opens a new glass vial. The official instructs the crew member, using his own grooving iron, to remove a sample from the outer tread block of the tire and then rotate 1/3 of a turn. Then remove a sample from the middle of the tire and rotate another 1/3 of a turn and remove a sample from the inside of the tire. Each sample is placed by the crew member into the open vial that the official is holding as it is removed. Once all samples are in the vial the top is screwed on and then it is sealed with a decal. The vial is then placed inside of the evidence bag and it is sealed. The crew member then signs on the bag along with the official agreeing it is sealed. The team is given a "receipt tab" which is attached to the bag. It has the unique number of the bag on it. When the sample arrives Blue Ridge confirms integrity of the bag and the sample as unopened and intact. Sample is then run. At no point does any official even touch the samples. So I have no idea how anyone can question the integrity of the sample. It is sealed in a tamperproof evidence bag inside a glass vial. It is no secret and I don't mind sharing it. People want transparency but when you give it to them they don't believe it.Modern Day Spec Wedge Racing
Comment
-
depending on who's cooking the soup.......as much as consistency is always the goal in anything produced for consumer use, it doesn't always happen.....for many reasons.
All of this circles back to the folks making the tires.....no hiding from that.
So to prevent all this soaking ,tell me again why they can't just make a tire that all of these supposed cheaters want to run consistently? They are the biggest and baddest dirt tire producer on the planet, surely they have scientists that can figure it out?
Or do the bookkeepers not want them too?Where is the move over flag when you need it?????
Comment
-
You are correct. Hoosier gives the sanctioning bodies a good idea where the benchmarks should kind of be around. I will tell you that the benchmarks that Lucas actually goes with are different then what WRG uses. It's not that Lucas allows more room for doping, they just know that their standards will have way less doubt with the results. If you get caught doping tires in Lucas, there really can be no argument that you didn't try to cheat. With WRG, their benchmarks are so ridiculous, they open themselves up to a plethora of debate.Originally posted by MasterSbilt_Racer View PostSomeone, somewhere, some time, gave the lab criteria for what does or doesn't meet the benchmark. No lab I have ever been involved in, does the testing and sets the pass/fail criteria. Testing has been most of my life.
Comment
-
Your comment is making me want to circle back. A few years ago, at Eldora, Bloomer, Rigsby, Essex, myself, and a couple racetrack officials were talking and tires came up. Scott started talking about how inconsistent the tires had become but he loved it because he knew he had a blatant advantage over everyone with his ability to save his tires. He joked that drivers were going to start trying to do stuff to their tires again to keep up with him. He said at one point that he had almost 20 samples taken that year alone cause people were so sure he was doping but not one of those tires ever came back dirty. Then came the next year at Eldora and that 5 person tire debacle happened. The common denominator in that situation? All 5 drivers bought their tires from different hoosier reps, but yet the test results came back with all the same wacky results. They were clearly faulty results, and the backdoor deal made behind closed doors solidified that, but I just found it to be very fishy that it happened the next year after all those tire tests he had the previous year.Originally posted by Barbecueboy View Postdepending on who's cooking the soup.......as much as consistency is always the goal in anything produced for consumer use, it doesn't always happen.....for many reasons.All of this circles back to the folks making the tires.....no hiding from that.So to prevent all this soaking ,tell me again why they can't just make a tire that all of these supposed cheaters want to run consistently? They are the biggest and baddest dirt tire producer on the planet, surely they have scientists that can figure it out?Or do the bookkeepers not want them too?
Comment
-
They test the tires against benchmarks that they the manufacturer themselves aren't 100% sure of what all is in them......again, IMO it's where most of the issue is here.
I like reading about how it's so different as to what's tested for and by whom when it comes to the different series....wasn't aware of that.Where is the move over flag when you need it?????
Comment
-
Is that the dirty little secret nobody wants to talk about?Where is the move over flag when you need it?????
Comment
-
Lets cut to the chase Kelly (no disrespect implied).....What info on these tests are sanctions like yours, are you all provided? Just pass or fail or the components that made it fail?Originally posted by flagone View PostI can 100% tell you that if it doesn't appear as the benchmark then it doesn't meet the benchmark and is called such. There are not "tolerances" set as you guys seem to suggest. It either conforms to the benchmark or it doesn't. They don't say it has 100 ppm of sea salt in it. They say it does not conform to the benchmark provided by the manufacturer. Blue Ridge has been testing racing tires and fuel for many years. Those that question them may not understand how science works or need someone to blame. Blue Ridge is bonded and licensed with over 25 years in the business. They have ZERO reason to screw anyone. The sanctions have ZERO reason to screw anyone. It pisses me off that anyone tries to point it at sanctions. I have a VERY specific process to collect samples. It is akin to a forensic process that maintains a chain of custody. The process for my events is: Tire is marked at scale. Official follows competitor to their hauler. Official instructs crew member which tire to use. Official collects date code and affixes this to the evidence bag along with the compound of the tire and sample name. The official then opens a new glass vial. The official instructs the crew member, using his own grooving iron, to remove a sample from the outer tread block of the tire and then rotate 1/3 of a turn. Then remove a sample from the middle of the tire and rotate another 1/3 of a turn and remove a sample from the inside of the tire. Each sample is placed by the crew member into the open vial that the official is holding as it is removed. Once all samples are in the vial the top is screwed on and then it is sealed with a decal. The vial is then placed inside of the evidence bag and it is sealed. The crew member then signs on the bag along with the official agreeing it is sealed. The team is given a "receipt tab" which is attached to the bag. It has the unique number of the bag on it. When the sample arrives Blue Ridge confirms integrity of the bag and the sample as unopened and intact. Sample is then run. At no point does any official even touch the samples. So I have no idea how anyone can question the integrity of the sample. It is sealed in a tamperproof evidence bag inside a glass vial. It is no secret and I don't mind sharing it. People want transparency but when you give it to them they don't believe it.
Comment
Comment