This is the type of violation where i have a very hard time believing it was intentional just because you have to know they're going to check that.
Michael Page
Collapse
X
-
The reason I was thinking someone made a mistake was I had heard from someone there that only one spring checked wrong.
Comment
-
So curiosity was killing the cat here. So i looked it up the valves are allowed to be shimmed a maximum of .020" to get seat pressure back after valve seat machining during a rebuild the seat pressure is 101# plus or minus 4# so basically 105#. If one takes the press release for its literal wording than it's must have measured wrong. But the two are directly related so if you told a engine guy your seat pressure was wrong he would tell you thats because your installed height is wrong. So to say the installed height is wrong could be interpreted as it's actually wrong or the spring pressure is incorrect since it is what controls that spec. Not trying to argue with anyone just thinking out loud
Comment
-
-
springs out of spec are more common than you think with these cheaper springs , thats why builders like Brad go through a bunch of springs just to get a set like they want that will comply with tech , i have bought a lot of the throw away,s from a local builder for half price that under normal applications were fine , this is the problem with a crate engines , if you want the very best LEGAL engine , you have to pay the piper .......Originally posted by billetbirdcage View PostI'm pulling numbers out of my arse, too lazy to look up the correct numbers
The install hieght is spec'ed like at 1.78 +/- a certain amount like .020
The spring pressure has a max pressure of like 110#
So while possible that a spring is out of spec and has 115# at the 1.76 to 1.8 install height allowed, it's not very common. They know the range of the springs and have rules set so it doesn't happen often, but it is possible. The pressure rule is more for non stock springs and springs that look just like the stock ones but are slightly stiffer. Many of those have real similar seat pressures but the open pressure is higher and hard to check without pulling spring off head to check the full range of the spring not just the on head test for seat pressure with a pull type on head spring checker.
Again, just going off the report/post why he was D/Q'ed it seems he was out of spec on the install height, I didn't see anything posted about pressure. I'm not trying to throw anyone under the bus but if it was indeed a install hieght only infraction, then that was done by someone not taking the time to do it right or didn't have the proper tools to set it correctly. Also not saying it was done on purpose either, could been a mistake, but with things like that I would figure a decent team doesn't make mistakes like that, when it's one of the first things checked
Comment
-
I've spent 2 full days on the Spintron for the 604, if you want to believe that the 5 or even 10# variance you see in springs makes a difference. . . . shrugs.Originally posted by fastford View Postsprings out of spec are more common than you think with these cheaper springs , thats why builders like Brad go through a bunch of springs just to get a set like they want that will comply with tech , i have bought a lot of the throw away,s from a local builder for half price that under normal applications were fine , this is the problem with a crate engines , if you want the very best LEGAL engine , you have to pay the piper .......
Most people would be shocked to what has an effect and what doesn't
Comment
-
It amazing that would be such a big advantage in such an old car. People are constantly talking about new cars being faster, and the fact that even new Mastersbilt aren't faster makes it more amazing one 10+ years old crossed the line before a new XR1. There was an article in Dirt Late Model Magazine about Page years ago and one of his sponsors talking about how he was one of the few drivers left who could cut the front clip off the car and rework it all by himself. I wonder it Tader knows about the mods Page has made to that chassis.
Comment
-
Not knocking anything Paige has done but just because it's a good crate car doesent mean it can compete with an open motor in it. Most guys in crates get caught up chasing the newer setups and their car couldn't spin a tire with the old stuff so alot of it is all for nothing.Originally posted by 84wedge View PostIt amazing that would be such a big advantage in such an old car. People are constantly talking about new cars being faster, and the fact that even new Mastersbilt aren't faster makes it more amazing one 10+ years old crossed the line before a new XR1. There was an article in Dirt Late Model Magazine about Page years ago and one of his sponsors talking about how he was one of the few drivers left who could cut the front clip off the car and rework it all by himself. I wonder it Tader knows about the mods Page has made to that chassis.
Comment
-
-
And I’m sure it’s been totally updated and has all the latest stuff. Not like it’s as is from 10 years ago for sure.Originally posted by Jking24 View PostNot knocking anything Paige has done but just because it's a good crate car doesent mean it can compete with an open motor in it. Most guys in crates get caught up chasing the newer setups and their car couldn't spin a tire with the old stuff so alot of it is all for nothing.Up in the air who my next “favorite†driver is. Really losing hope on Bloomer getting anywhere back to “normalâ€.
Comment
-
^^Page was saying in a DOD article last year that nothing was done to that car. I'm not buying it either. Even in crates. But, what Jking said has some merit as well.Modern Day Spec Wedge Racing
Comment
-
i guess i am a bit behind the times billet , tell me how you can tell the difference a spring makes on a spintron ? , now i can see a dyno , but i thought a spintron is more for breaking in an engine , not evaluating if 10# of seat pressure makes a difference in the performance of the engine.....Originally posted by billetbirdcage View PostI've spent 2 full days on the Spintron for the 604, if you want to believe that the 5 or even 10# variance you see in springs makes a difference. . . . shrugs.
Most people would be shocked to what has an effect and what doesn't
Comment
-
Spintron is not for breaking in anything, it's to measure valve train performance and stability. The valves go out of control at 6750 rpm, anything you change shows up on the graph as far as valve bounce, lofting, spring surge and just generally how well it follows the cam profile are different RPM's.Originally posted by fastford View Posti guess i am a bit behind the times billet , tell me how you can tell the difference a spring makes on a spintron ? , now i can see a dyno , but i thought a spintron is more for breaking in an engine , not evaluating if 10# of seat pressure makes a difference in the performance of the engine.....
What I'm saying is those Good/matched/higher pressure stock valve springs that have say 8# more pressure then the others:
1: once the engine runs at 1200 idle RPM the valve spring has cycled 10 times a second. Do you really think it is still the same 8# higher then the other springs? Take one of those new springs and cycle it 10 times in a vise and retest the spring and tell me if it's not about the same as the other springs or didn't lose a ton of the 8# advantage? (this isn't also getting the spring hot to 200+ degrees)
2: Pressure isn't the only factor on controlling the valve, sometimes less pressure can be more stable at times if the right things are met. There is a reason Cup engines only have 90/100# of seat pressure and can run 10K RPM, it's not all about pressure.
3. Now a 604 makes no power at the 6750 RPM anyways, but getting more RPM allows you to run more gear if needed and not destroy the engine or allows you to chip the engine higher. My point is that those match springs or slightly higher poundage you pay a premium for have no real effect on the valve train going nuts and trying to self destruct at 6750.
4. When you have weak push rods, rocker studs, rockers and etc, adding unneeded spring pressure can just make flex/lofting/surge worse and actually make the valve train go unstable earlier (not always but many times). Many times it makes the valve not follow the cam profile and hurts power.
Obviously your not allow to change any of those things (only stock parts) but testing that stuff showed what mattered and what didn't. Not giving away any results but just maybe having a shorter install hieght (min allowed) and a weaker spring (low end of the springs ranges) could allow you to stay under the max seat pressure but since the spring is closer to coil bind, it surges less and increases the RPM before it goes nuts (again just a scenario)Last edited by billetbirdcage; 01-20-2021, 07:30 PM.
Comment
Comment