Have I got last weekend right here??? ....

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • W2Racing09
    Senior Member
    • Apr 2014
    • 1691

    #16
    Originally posted by fastford View Post
    im not talking about this from a track perspective, since ive never owned or ran one, but we do field a limited late model with the rules being an all steel engine and a weight of 2300 lbs, which WAS kind of a standard set of rules here in the south east for years, now your telling me you think its fair for me to have to compete with an equal , if not a more powerful , all aluminum engine at the same weight ? whats fair about this? I say keep the all steel engines separate from the supers, if a track does not have a crate class, then give the 602 a weight break, but not the 604, because of the aluminum heads, but keep the all aluminum engines in supers only.
    Here in the Mid Atlantic you couldn't give a 604 away to a LLM driver. They have absolutely no chance at any race against the steel block 358 LMs in Central PA or in the LLM division at Winchester/Hagerstown/Bedford/etc.

    A CT525 on the other hand should not get any breaks when running with the Steel Blocks. I would consider them as close to equal as it gets with the Steel Blocks having a little bit of advantage when conditions are WFO and the CT525 having the edge when the track is slick.

    Thanks,
    Jeff.

    Comment

    • fastford
      Senior Member
      • Dec 2008
      • 4059

      #17
      Originally posted by W2Racing09 View Post
      Here in the Mid Atlantic you couldn't give a 604 away to a LLM driver. They have absolutely no chance at any race against the steel block 358 LMs in Central PA or in the LLM division at Winchester/Hagerstown/Bedford/etc.

      A CT525 on the other hand should not get any breaks when running with the Steel Blocks. I would consider them as close to equal as it gets with the Steel Blocks having a little bit of advantage when conditions are WFO and the CT525 having the edge when the track is slick.

      Thanks,
      Jeff.
      I agree about the 604 stuff, even though a guy won half the races down here with one last year until someone tore him down and he was found to be illegal on some technicality, our limited don't run steel block and aluminum heads, there 358 all steel, your talking close to 200 lbs heaver than a 525, that's to much difference to have to run same min. weight

      Comment

      • W2Racing09
        Senior Member
        • Apr 2014
        • 1691

        #18
        Originally posted by fastford View Post
        I agree about the 604 stuff, even though a guy won half the races down here with one last year until someone tore him down and he was found to be illegal on some technicality, our limited don't run steel block and aluminum heads, there 358 all steel, your talking close to 200 lbs heaver than a 525, that's to much difference to have to run same min. weight
        I think most Steel Blocks have 100+ more HP than the CT525. I think in many situations 100+ HP is worth 200lb (more likely 125 - 150 because the CT525 would be under the limit and need to add weight). Obviously in some track types you could win an SLM race with a Pure Stock so nothing can be done there but when the track is fast at all that HP will have an edge.

        Thanks,
        Jeff.

        Comment

        • Punisher88
          Senior Member
          • Nov 2014
          • 495

          #19
          The 525 is much much closer than that. Most probably have MORE torque than the steel motors. Which was evident this weekend at the bash. I ram second in the steel block class to madden and off the corners mine was lifting the left front with so much traction and using all the motor and he was just pulling away. And I've also talked to a couple guys that said on the dyno with all lightweight bolt ons that it has 580 at the flywheel. So if that is true then it is probably only about 20 horsepower short of some of the best steel motors made. And to add to the torque part. The torque curve is basically a straight line. It isn't nearly as much of a spike and drop like a built motor.

          Comment

          • fastford
            Senior Member
            • Dec 2008
            • 4059

            #20
            congrats on a good run punisher, if they had not allowed that BS, you would have won. by the way I have seen a 525 dyno a little over 600 hp fully tuned, but its not the power as much as its the weight distribution. if both cars has to weigh the same, the car with 200lbs less noes weight has a huge advantage, now on a real tacky track, might not be as bad, but about june around here and when the tracks go slick, , you can forget it...

            Comment

            • Punisher88
              Senior Member
              • Nov 2014
              • 495

              #21
              The track was as locked down as could be. He had me beat on power big time but I out ran several 525's as well. It was a good learning experience to run with someone like that though.

              Comment

              • Barbecueboy
                Senior Member
                • Mar 2013
                • 18116

                #22
                Originally posted by Punisher88 View Post
                The track was as locked down as could be. He had me beat on power big time but I out ran several 525's as well. It was a good learning experience to run with someone like that though.
                It's nice to see an actual racers point of view on the subject........your opinion and observations actually carry a lot of weight.

                Congrats on a good run btw......
                Where is the move over flag when you need it?????

                Comment

                • W2Racing09
                  Senior Member
                  • Apr 2014
                  • 1691

                  #23
                  Thanks for your comments Punisher.

                  I would like to note that while I have seen the 525s run well with the Steel Blocks (in fact I think a bunch of tracks in GA run the 525/604/Steel Blocks together) I have never made a habit of campaigning and saying they should be run together.

                  All of my comments on the last post and the point of most of my comments on this post are saying that they should be run in the SLM division with a weight break against other open aluminium engines.

                  Comment

                  • fastford
                    Senior Member
                    • Dec 2008
                    • 4059

                    #24
                    Originally posted by W2Racing09 View Post
                    Thanks for your comments Punisher.

                    I would like to note that while I have seen the 525s run well with the Steel Blocks (in fact I think a bunch of tracks in GA run the 525/604/Steel Blocks together) I have never made a habit of campaigning and saying they should be run together.

                    All of my comments on the last post and the point of most of my comments on this post are saying that they should be run in the SLM division with a weight break against other open aluminium engines.
                    I agree with you on this, the only question is how much? if you give them to much of a weight break, it would not be fair to the opens on a dry slick track, if you don't give them enough, then the 525 would suffer on a tacky track. I just looked at the southern all stars rules and you may as well run open, or 525, there not giving the spec engines any thing anymore.

                    Comment

                    • Punisher88
                      Senior Member
                      • Nov 2014
                      • 495

                      #25
                      I think on bigger 3/8ths tracks like eams they are more suited for the steel motor class. They are much closer in lap times amd they make them run 50 extra pounds in front of the mid plate to account for the aluminum block, which is probably about all the difference there is since I run the brodix aluminum spec heads on my car. I do think it could be handicapped a bit more than what it is now though. Maybe by adding another 50 lbs anywhere on the car. But I did also outrun several 525's this past weekend also so it could have just been the guy driving the car. But on smaller than 3/8ths tracks like senoia or talladega it is definitely a super motor.

                      Comment

                      • Bubstr
                        Senior Member
                        • Feb 2008
                        • 3734

                        #26
                        I just don't see this handicap system working with touring series or Crown Jewel type races. If it did, the fast teams would come in the gate with 2 open engines, 2 crate engines and 2 limited engines, then decide which one was needed. There went any cost savings out the window and any local racer that had hopes of finding the needle in the hay stack.

                        It may work for a regional series or local nightly racing and be a good excuse to keep purses the same or lower them. There has to be a better way for the racer with big time dreams and small time pocket book. The Deery bros., limited series puts on a great show in the Iowa area, but they have to buy that big motor to compete in the open shows. The SLM isn't for every driver. They aren't even for every track and that is what makes them special and why some fans only go to those races. Those fans, know what the best of the best are. They want to see Bloomquist, Moyer, Lannigan, Richards, ONeal, Mars, Owens, Clanton, McDowel, Davenport and on and on. When you convince these guys to give a handicap to guys that spent a lot less than they did, to be competitive, you may have a race, if there isn't a real SLM race that day somewhere else.

                        Even if the handicap race is great racing, it will be a second class race. A $15 at the gate race, not a $25 $30 race. Not saying these racers aren't good, just saying, you can't be the best, unless you beat the best. That is the mentality of most traveling race fans.

                        Comment

                        • W2Racing09
                          Senior Member
                          • Apr 2014
                          • 1691

                          #27
                          Originally posted by Bubstr View Post
                          I just don't see this handicap system working with touring series or Crown Jewel type races. If it did, the fast teams would come in the gate with 2 open engines, 2 crate engines and 2 limited engines, then decide which one was needed. There went any cost savings out the window and any local racer that had hopes of finding the needle in the hay stack.

                          It may work for a regional series or local nightly racing and be a good excuse to keep purses the same or lower them. There has to be a better way for the racer with big time dreams and small time pocket book. The Deery bros., limited series puts on a great show in the Iowa area, but they have to buy that big motor to compete in the open shows. The SLM isn't for every driver. They aren't even for every track and that is what makes them special and why some fans only go to those races. Those fans, know what the best of the best are. They want to see Bloomquist, Moyer, Lannigan, Richards, ONeal, Mars, Owens, Clanton, McDowel, Davenport and on and on. When you convince these guys to give a handicap to guys that spent a lot less than they did, to be competitive, you may have a race, if there isn't a real SLM race that day somewhere else.

                          Even if the handicap race is great racing, it will be a second class race. A $15 at the gate race, not a $25 $30 race. Not saying these racers aren't good, just saying, you can't be the best, unless you beat the best. That is the mentality of most traveling race fans.
                          I certainly don't think it would be considered handicap racing to give a certain motor a weight break. As long as you are not slowing down the open cars then everything is fine. The 100lb weight break for the 525 and the bigger spoiler works at a lot of tracks around the country. I don't think that rules set would make the 525 have an advantage on any surface, but would help them to keep up on smaller tracks.

                          Now if there were additional advantages given to the 525 the easy way to stop people from bringing the six motors to the track is to make them declare what they are running at the beginning of the season.

                          I'm running a Modified series in the Mid Atlantic this season and we have a few different rules packages based on the motor. RoD/Western PA cars run at standard weight, cars with 383CI and smaller (IMCA or VMS) get a 50lb weight break and Crate motors get a 100lb weight break.

                          At the beginning of the season we are teching and the driver will get a sticker -- the standard ones get a sticker with just our logo, the 383 cars get our logo with a 383 below it and the crate cars get out logo with crate below it. That is what you run all season, if a driver changes motors they run at the standard weight for the rest of the season with no weight breaks.

                          There are very few circumstances in which a crate will have an advantage, but I certainly don't want to see the big money teams come in and buy a crate just to have an advantage on those days too.

                          Thanks,
                          Jeff.

                          Comment

                          • fastford
                            Senior Member
                            • Dec 2008
                            • 4059

                            #28
                            Originally posted by Punisher88 View Post
                            I think on bigger 3/8ths tracks like eams they are more suited for the steel motor class. They are much closer in lap times amd they make them run 50 extra pounds in front of the mid plate to account for the aluminum block, which is probably about all the difference there is since I run the brodix aluminum spec heads on my car. I do think it could be handicapped a bit more than what it is now though. Maybe by adding another 50 lbs anywhere on the car. But I did also outrun several 525's this past weekend also so it could have just been the guy driving the car. But on smaller than 3/8ths tracks like senoia or talladega it is definitely a super motor.
                            I didn't realize they were letting you run spec engines with the Limited's down there, that clears a lot of things up, where we race limited is ALL STEEL only , I just went to eams web site and the limited rules say sealed crate engine only, is allowing these other engines something they do just for the bigger racer?
                            Last edited by fastford; 03-16-2015, 08:58 AM.

                            Comment

                            • Punisher88
                              Senior Member
                              • Nov 2014
                              • 495

                              #29
                              There limited class is called eams late model. The limited class you looked at is a 602 late model class. But they aren't spec engines. National late model series has a spec head the brodix makes. It's a 23 degree aluminum head that is the same mold at the bow tie vortec and flows around the same. We can't do anything to them but do a valve job and angle mill them. The runners have to stay factory. They make the same hp as the steel heads they just weigh less is the biggest advantage.

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X