anyone use a plastic fan?

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • smokey 4 president
    Member
    • Jan 2008
    • 82

    #1

    anyone use a plastic fan?

    Wonderin how a plastic fan would do. Seems like the blades would flatten out at high rpm. Anybody use one?
    Well it doesn't say that I can't
  • stock car driver
    Senior Member
    • Jul 2007
    • 3233

    #2
    No

    I run a steep pitched 4 blade steel 18 or 19 inch and have chassis dynoed with it off and there was no hp difference to the rear wheels.

    Comment

    • Graff Spee
      Senior Member
      • Feb 2008
      • 881

      #3
      Originally posted by stock car driver View Post
      No

      I run a steep pitched 4 blade steel 18 or 19 inch and have chassis dynoed with it off and there was no hp difference to the rear wheels.
      You must live by these words to be victorious! ;-)

      Comment

      • hogracer3d
        Senior Member
        • Sep 2007
        • 511

        #4
        Check your rules, plastic fans are not legal at any track around here

        They are specifically excluded, as a safety hazard

        Comment

        • Egoracing
          Senior Member
          • May 2007
          • 4852

          #5
          Originally posted by hogracer3d View Post
          Check your rules, plastic fans are not legal at any track around here

          They are specifically excluded, as a safety hazard
          I think that is funny, I have see a few plastic come apart but they usually only damage the radiator if anything but, the tracks will allow the cheap flex fans that are riveted together and I have seen them come apart and cut through a factory steel hood or fender and keep going. We were at Desoto speedway (big 3/8 mile asphalt) once and the aluminum paddle from a fan fell from the sky and landed in the pits on the pit road. The pits are WELL behind the stands and the cars were on the front straight when it hit the ground.

          Comment

          • carowner73
            Senior Member
            • Dec 2009
            • 174

            #6
            Originally posted by stock car driver View Post
            No

            I run a steep pitched 4 blade steel 18 or 19 inch and have chassis dynoed with it off and there was no hp difference to the rear wheels.
            what he said

            Comment

            • bushracing67
              Senior Member
              • Oct 2007
              • 904

              #7
              i have been running a plastic fan for several years, prolly doesn't pull the air a 4 blade pulls, but they are a lot lighter and create way less harmonics.... if you can run one with out cooling issues i say go for it

              Comment

              • cautrell05
                Senior Member
                • May 2007
                • 341

                #8
                I have ran them for over 10 years. never had one or seen one come apart. I run them in all but the hottest days. If its over 90 i will put my 6 blade on and it will pull another 10-20 degrees off but if its in the low 80s the plastic runs around 210.

                Nick

                Comment

                • SRXSRULE
                  Senior Member
                  • Jan 2011
                  • 217

                  #9
                  Would you guys believe it if I told ya on back to back dyno pulls that a 17" plastic fan lost torque and hp compared to a 17" steel 6 blade fan Eric

                  Comment

                  • bushracing67
                    Senior Member
                    • Oct 2007
                    • 904

                    #10
                    no, im sure there was some other variable that caused the numbers change, no one expects the fan to make more horsepower, but i bet my water pump will last longer with out an out of balance 8lb gm 4 blade on there

                    Comment

                    • SRXSRULE
                      Senior Member
                      • Jan 2011
                      • 217

                      #11
                      It wasn't just one pull. We made three pulls with each fan. Same result each time. You would be surprised what does and does NOT work when you spend the time testing. Eric

                      Comment

                      • bushracing67
                        Senior Member
                        • Oct 2007
                        • 904

                        #12
                        if that is the case, that would leave me to believe that the plastic fan was pulling more air than the other blades you tested, i see no other reason that it would take away hp

                        Comment

                        • DaveBauerSS6
                          Senior Member
                          • Jun 2010
                          • 566

                          #13
                          Customer called me out on a noise. He was running a plastic fan on a 1 to 1 pulley setup. Made a loud flutter noise at 4000 and up. Put a timing lite on it and the blades were turning over center, between the hub mounting area and the blade where it folds 90 degrees. Went to a 30% reduction and the noise went away.
                          Gator Engineering

                          Comment

                          • Racingtech
                            Member
                            • Oct 2007
                            • 74

                            #14
                            The plastic fan will work

                            I have used the plastic fan for years with no prblems even on hot days. You have to have a good shroud and space it up close enought to the radiator. I have had the metal steep pitch 4 blade pull the mounting hub off the water pump when I spaced it out close to the radiator. Also in a wreck once the radiator was pushed into the fan and the damage to the radiator was repairable. Good luck

                            Comment

                            • let-r-eat
                              Senior Member
                              • May 2007
                              • 2319

                              #15
                              Remember.

                              Engines want air! Nice fresh cool air......The better the fan works the more Cool air is available........

                              The plastic fans won't move near as much air as a nicely pitched steel fan. They flatten out too much......
                              BUCKLE UP NOW, YA HEAR?

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X