R2C dirt problems

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • ben_seaton
    Junior Member
    • Sep 2012
    • 19

    #16
    Originally posted by stock car driver
    How would you get oil in your carb from a R2C filter? They are DRY, lol.

    Obviously your not talking about the same filter.
    i appreciate your willingness to jump straight to assuming my ignorance. I did mean more dirt was noticed in the carb and more dirt noticed in the oil when running the R2C with the outerwear cover on it.

    Again, I have nothing against R2C, it just didn't work for me.

    Comment

    • stock car driver
      Senior Member
      • Jul 2007
      • 3233

      #17
      Originally posted by ben_seaton View Post
      i appreciate your willingness to jump straight to assuming my ignorance. I did mean more dirt was noticed in the carb and more dirt noticed in the oil when running the R2C with the outerwear cover on it.

      Again, I have nothing against R2C, it just didn't work for me.
      The only way to get much dirt past the r2c and the outer wear is if YOU did something wrong.

      Like your hood rests on the top and (not a nice word)(not a nice word)(not a nice word)(not a nice word)s it sideways off the base etc.

      Ive talked to some people who replaced a 4 inch kn with a 4 inch r2c and somehow didnt notice the r2c is actually 5 inches tall overall so their hood was on it.

      Nothing filters as good.

      Comment

      • 77modracer
        Senior Member
        • Mar 2009
        • 187

        #18
        Bollinger 77 racing

        I used to get a thin film of mud in the bottom of my intake when i used the k/n style air cleaner !!!!! I then switched R2c ,no mud or dirt residue in the intake ,120 nights 2 years not one problem!!
        R2C is the best product out there !!!

        Comment

        • backspace
          Senior Member
          • May 2007
          • 984

          #19
          I have never ran a R2C,,,but here is a tip to check anyones filter for dirt. Take your bottom and top to bench and clean the insides with a scotch brite pad. Wipe clean with mineral spirits or carb cleaner. Then spray paint them with a high quality "gloss black" paint. After the races,,pull the air cleaner apart and look for dust on top and bottom. I will not disclose brand names on here,but there are some you don't even want,,some are better than others,,dirt is your enemy here folks,,,,control it to the max and you engine will live longer. I will tell you this,,the best one I have found costs less than a oil change on the mod..I will not use those foam filters around any air cleaner,,talk about a power robber when it gets a little dirty,,,,,These are just my opinions as I have tried this test for several years.
          We build fast race cars,,not race cars fast!

          Comment

          • kevan3x
            Junior Member
            • Jul 2009
            • 15

            #20
            r2c

            i also had major problems with r2c this year had good luck with one first year this year cyl. was worn bad , never had had problem with k&n type had same block 6 years with out reboring but this one lasted 1

            Comment

            • usafracer
              Senior Member
              • Jun 2010
              • 554

              #21
              Originally posted by kevan3x View Post
              i also had major problems with r2c this year had good luck with one first year this year cyl. was worn bad , never had had problem with k&n type had same block 6 years with out reboring but this one lasted 1
              I find it hard to believe that the filter caused the wear. I would like to think that you would have taken the time to check your filter and carb for signs of dirt.
              My sarcasm is a pre-emptive strike to your stupidity!!

              Comment

              • let-r-eat
                Senior Member
                • May 2007
                • 2319

                #22
                I'm an old fashioned tech neck when it comes to filters. Someone a bunch smarter than I said once while talking about air filters why this such and such filter was so clean after a race on such a dusty track? Smart wise man said, "Filter not filtering." When I look at a filter this always sticks in my mind. What does a filter do with what it filters?The best filter will not be good for HP nor will the worst filter be good for durability. Compromise.Nothing against the R2c or K^N or other filters but I'm old fashioned a go with the old tried and true. Paper. HP is likely not the biggest factor in winning the race anyway.
                BUCKLE UP NOW, YA HEAR?

                Comment

                • stock car driver
                  Senior Member
                  • Jul 2007
                  • 3233

                  #23
                  Originally posted by let-r-eat View Post
                  I'm an old fashioned tech neck when it comes to filters. Someone a bunch smarter than I said once while talking about air filters why this such and such filter was so clean after a race on such a dusty track? Smart wise man said, "Filter not filtering." When I look at a filter this always sticks in my mind. What does a filter do with what it filters?The best filter will not be good for HP nor will the worst filter be good for durability. Compromise.Nothing against the R2c or K^N or other filters but I'm old fashioned a go with the old tried and true. Paper. HP is likely not the biggest factor in winning the race anyway.
                  I had dirty venturis when I ran paper, even with grease on the top and bottom.

                  R2C holds the dirt, click on the video I posted above.

                  ANYONE claiming to have issues with dirt in their motor with a R2C needs to look at what THEY have done and how THEY have it installed, its not the filter letting the dirt in.

                  Comment

                  • stock car driver
                    Senior Member
                    • Jul 2007
                    • 3233

                    #24

                    Comment

                    • HEAVY DUTY
                      Senior Member
                      • Jun 2007
                      • 796

                      #25
                      Originally posted by let-r-eat View Post
                      I'm an old fashioned tech neck when it comes to filters. Someone a bunch smarter than I said once while talking about air filters why this such and such filter was so clean after a race on such a dusty track? Smart wise man said, "Filter not filtering." When I look at a filter this always sticks in my mind. What does a filter do with what it filters?The best filter will not be good for HP nor will the worst filter be good for durability. Compromise.Nothing against the R2c or K^N or other filters but I'm old fashioned a go with the old tried and true. Paper. HP is likely not the biggest factor in winning the race anyway.
                      We used a paper 14 x 4 on the chassis dyno compared to a k&n style 14 x 4 with 2 nights of dirt. The k & n style made 7 less HP than no air cleaner. The paper one was what Allstar sells, ( not a WIX ) and I thought the motor seized up. It about died at about 6000 and the headers turned red. We killed that dyno run, and dont know about the power. We were going to 7500 with the other filters. I seriously thought we seized the engine up. We checked it out, and took the filter off, re ran it , and got the same results as before.

                      Comment

                      • let-r-eat
                        Senior Member
                        • May 2007
                        • 2319

                        #26
                        I'm not saying that other filters don't work. What I'm saying is simple. Paper works, is working now all over the country, and will continue to work.
                        BUCKLE UP NOW, YA HEAR?

                        Comment

                        • Egoracing
                          Senior Member
                          • May 2007
                          • 4852

                          #27
                          Originally posted by let-r-eat View Post
                          I'm not saying that other filters don't work. What I'm saying is simple. Paper works, is working now all over the country, and will continue to work.
                          Not all paper is equal though, Wix is about the best, others can choke the engine and could lead to engine damage.

                          Comment

                          • HEAVY DUTY
                            Senior Member
                            • Jun 2007
                            • 796

                            #28
                            Originally posted by Egoracing View Post
                            Not all paper is equal though, Wix is about the best, others can choke the engine and could lead to engine damage.
                            I found that out. Luckily I was on the dyno and shut it down. I know guys that use the Wix or Napa gold ( made by Wix). I have also seen catalogs that listed the CFM of the filter. Some paper filters were 500 to 650 to start before they got dirty. That dyno run, made me get a top flow and a 5" filter to make sure I had enough air when dirty.

                            Comment

                            • hot_rod
                              Member
                              • Jun 2010
                              • 99

                              #29
                              I have been looking at getting a R2C for my Super Street. I was curious as to whether or not it was worth spending the money and get the actual R2C filter base that fits the 4150 carb? Or will the filter function properly with the regular old Aluminum base that we have been using with the K&N style of filter. Im a lot like Jeff and dont clean my filter nearly as often as I should. We lost an engine last year because of it, so this year I am wanting to upgrade filters. Just not sure as the $100+ base is worth the extra money. I realize that $100 is cheaper than a new bottom end, but if it will work fine with the same base. I would rather spend $100+ on something else.

                              Comment

                              • dirtrace09
                                Senior Member
                                • Aug 2007
                                • 746

                                #30
                                I found that out. Luckily I was on the dyno and shut it down. I know guys that use the Wix or Napa gold ( made by Wix). I have also seen catalogs that listed the CFM of the filter. Some paper filters were 500 to 650 to start before they got dirty. That dyno run, made me get a top flow and a 5" filter to make sure I had enough air when dirty.

                                Have you had the dirt in the your carb with this setup? I had looked at them before but wasn't sure how they would work.

                                Comment

                                Working...
                                X