Left-Rear Weight

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Stede Bonnet
    Senior Member
    • Sep 2016
    • 325

    #31
    Originally posted by ReignMan23 View Post
    Hopefully someone smarter than me could shed some light here. I always thought the lighter the better but it seems that thinking is changing. What is the deal w/adding weight directly to the left rear? How is this helping the cars? At what lengths are guys willing to go to put weight on the left rear? Are there any rules preventing the addition of left-rear weight? Is this beneficial for a tacky and a slick track? Any information would be greatly appreciated. Thanks
    Your a few months late to this discussion, but in synopsis it has to do with the difference between sprung and un-sprung, dynamic and static weight, plus aerodynamic versus mechanical grip. All things being equal, up to a point, the tire with the greatest load has the most traction. What this means is as setups have evolved since 1998, when the spring behind setup went mainstream, that introduced massive instantaneous mechanical rear traction or "Drive". The problem was though it was generally too much of a good thing and the cars were a handful to drive, they tended to go in unpredictable directions when you let off the fuel and a lot of shocks were ripped apart in the process. Prior to 1998 the typical RF spring was 550#, but as the setups have progressed or digressed depending on your POV, the RF spring got softer and softer until now its barely strong enough to hold the car up sitting still. What they realized was if they softened the RF, all the energy thrust into the chassis at the LR by the rods hiking the car up could be absorbed into the RF by softening the spring, thus keeping the front end on the ground. The tradeoff though was loss of "Drive" for better "Steering", so in comes the bump stops and coil binding setups, this way you could have your cake and eat it too. The bumps allowed you to run a soft spring on the RF so you could keep the frontend down, but at a specific set point in travel you could induce the lost mechanical grip, but its a fine line and requires expensive shock packages and testing to control effectively. In the middle of all this they found that keeping the nose piece as close to the surface of the track as they could further allowed them to introduce more drive and the aero downforce on the nose would help them to turn. In the midst of all this other parts of the car were developing as well, lighter and lighter doo-dads, low friction this and that, and HP peaking beyond 900!!!

    Now skip forward to 2014 and an enterprising young man named Kevin Rumley had noticed a short coming in the much worshiped and ballyhooed 4 link rear suspension. He devised a component that would further enhance rear traction and still have a car that would turn, add to that a young talented driver with something to prove and you get the 2015 Lucas Oil season. Now along the way everyone is scrambling to match speed with the Rumley car and pulling out all the stops, more power is demanded from engine builders, but getting all that HP to stay hooked all night is nearly impossible and TC is illegal, so what do you do?

    Increased Load equals more traction, up to a point. Just adding weight to the chassis on the LR won't work because it will upset the balance. You see adding weight to the chassis is "Sprung weight" or weight carried by the springs, which moves around during body roll and cornering, so in order to get the weight to stay in the LR it must be un-sprung weight, ie axle tubes, bird cages and suspension links. Having the rear end be heavier on the left side, on its own, helps more of the static weight stay on the LR for when you need it at corner exit. Now the reason for the heavy wheel spacers and brake rotors is two fold, one you get the added un-sprung weight for the LR, but two, you get a dampening of the engine torque and less wheel spin thru the centrifugal force, essentially legal traction control. They could've saved everyone a lot of money had they dealt with the shock/spring behind the axle back in the day and enforced the body rules and the 1 shock per wheel rule, but Pandora's box has been opened and the snakes are out. Bon Voyage.
    Politically Incorrect.

    Comment

    • Stede Bonnet
      Senior Member
      • Sep 2016
      • 325

      #32
      Originally posted by flagone View Post
      The chassis is significantly stronger and less likely to break than an axle tube, radius rod or birdcage under dynamic motion or in an impact.

      You can do 2 heavy cages but I don't think you will see anyone doing that.

      Sleeves are no cheaper than buying an axle tube.
      The axle feels the same weight regardless of whether its a heavy tube or frame, weight is weight, 2300# is 2300# and it all gets fed thru the birdcage into the axle, so I call BS on it being at risk to break. If y'all were gonna worry about axle's breaking it should've been when they started propping the LR up on 2 solids rods instead of the weight being fed progressively thru a spring.
      Politically Incorrect.

      Comment

      • chop6259
        Junior Member
        • Dec 2012
        • 21

        #33
        Originally posted by Stede Bonnet View Post
        Your a few months late to this discussion, but in synopsis it has to do with the difference between sprung and un-sprung, dynamic and static weight, plus aerodynamic versus mechanical grip. All things being equal, up to a point, the tire with the greatest load has the most traction. What this means is as setups have evolved since 1998, when the spring behind setup went mainstream, that introduced massive instantaneous mechanical rear traction or "Drive". The problem was though it was generally too much of a good thing and the cars were a handful to drive, they tended to go in unpredictable directions when you let off the fuel and a lot of shocks were ripped apart in the process. Prior to 1998 the typical RF spring was 550#, but as the setups have progressed or digressed depending on your POV, the RF spring got softer and softer until now its barely strong enough to hold the car up sitting still. What they realized was if they softened the RF, all the energy thrust into the chassis at the LR by the rods hiking the car up could be absorbed into the RF by softening the spring, thus keeping the front end on the ground. The tradeoff though was loss of "Drive" for better "Steering", so in comes the bump stops and coil binding setups, this way you could have your cake and eat it too. The bumps allowed you to run a soft spring on the RF so you could keep the frontend down, but at a specific set point in travel you could induce the lost mechanical grip, but its a fine line and requires expensive shock packages and testing to control effectively. In the middle of all this they found that keeping the nose piece as close to the surface of the track as they could further allowed them to introduce more drive and the aero downforce on the nose would help them to turn. In the midst of all this other parts of the car were developing as well, lighter and lighter doo-dads, low friction this and that, and HP peaking beyond 900!!! Now skip forward to 2014 and an enterprising young man named Kevin Rumley had noticed a short coming in the much worshiped and ballyhooed 4 link rear suspension. He devised a component that would further enhance rear traction and still have a car that would turn, add to that a young talented driver with something to prove and you get the 2015 Lucas Oil season. Now along the way everyone is scrambling to match speed with the Rumley car and pulling out all the stops, more power is demanded from engine builders, but getting all that HP to stay hooked all night is nearly impossible and TC is illegal, so what do you do? Increased Load equals more traction, up to a point. Just adding weight to the chassis on the LR won't work because it will upset the balance. You see adding weight to the chassis is "Sprung weight" or weight carried by the springs, which moves around during body roll and cornering, so in order to get the weight to stay in the LR it must be un-sprung weight, ie axle tubes, bird cages and suspension links. Having the rear end be heavier on the left side, on its own, helps more of the static weight stay on the LR for when you need it at corner exit. Now the reason for the heavy wheel spacers and brake rotors is two fold, one you get the added un-sprung weight for the LR, but two, you get a dampening of the engine torque and less wheel spin thru the centrifugal force, essentially legal traction control. They could've saved everyone a lot of money had they dealt with the shock/spring behind the axle back in the day and enforced the body rules and the 1 shock per wheel rule, but Pandora's box has been opened and the snakes are out. Bon Voyage.
        Well, reading through some of these post, I was going to make a response, but Stede Bonnet did a pretty good job of summing up the main points. The one thing I might add is that you have to recognize that force is developed at the contact patch through three paths: elastic (i.e. springs shocks), kinematic (i.e. the bars), and the unsprung mass. If the car is up on the bars, the elastic path has been pretty much diminished leaving the forces to mainly reach the tire through the bars and the unsprung mass. One other thing you have to remember is that the kinematic forces are developed as a reaction to lateral and longitudinal forces at the contact patch. If at any time while up on the bars, the driver has to work the throttle, there goes your kinematic path when forward thrust is removed. The only thing left is what little bit of force the shock will carry and the unsprung mass. Increasing the unsprung mass on the left rear will help to keep the tire loaded as the driver works the throttle while on the bars.http://www.bartlettmotorsportengineering.com

        Comment

        • cjsracing
          Senior Member
          • May 2007
          • 842

          #34
          I'm just glad my sanctioning body didn't adopt these "Uniform" rules.

          Comment

          • chupp n bloomer fan
            Senior Member
            • May 2007
            • 11526

            #35
            Originally posted by Stede Bonnet View Post
            Your a few months late to this discussion, but in synopsis it has to do with the difference between sprung and un-sprung, dynamic and static weight, plus aerodynamic versus mechanical grip. All things being equal, up to a point, the tire with the greatest load has the most traction. What this means is as setups have evolved since 1998, when the spring behind setup went mainstream, that introduced massive instantaneous mechanical rear traction or "Drive". The problem was though it was generally too much of a good thing and the cars were a handful to drive, they tended to go in unpredictable directions when you let off the fuel and a lot of shocks were ripped apart in the process. Prior to 1998 the typical RF spring was 550#, but as the setups have progressed or digressed depending on your POV, the RF spring got softer and softer until now its barely strong enough to hold the car up sitting still. What they realized was if they softened the RF, all the energy thrust into the chassis at the LR by the rods hiking the car up could be absorbed into the RF by softening the spring, thus keeping the front end on the ground. The tradeoff though was loss of "Drive" for better "Steering", so in comes the bump stops and coil binding setups, this way you could have your cake and eat it too. The bumps allowed you to run a soft spring on the RF so you could keep the frontend down, but at a specific set point in travel you could induce the lost mechanical grip, but its a fine line and requires expensive shock packages and testing to control effectively. In the middle of all this they found that keeping the nose piece as close to the surface of the track as they could further allowed them to introduce more drive and the aero downforce on the nose would help them to turn. In the midst of all this other parts of the car were developing as well, lighter and lighter doo-dads, low friction this and that, and HP peaking beyond 900!!!

            Now skip forward to 2014 and an enterprising young man named Kevin Rumley had noticed a short coming in the much worshiped and ballyhooed 4 link rear suspension. He devised a component that would further enhance rear traction and still have a car that would turn, add to that a young talented driver with something to prove and you get the 2015 Lucas Oil season. Now along the way everyone is scrambling to match speed with the Rumley car and pulling out all the stops, more power is demanded from engine builders, but getting all that HP to stay hooked all night is nearly impossible and TC is illegal, so what do you do?

            Increased Load equals more traction, up to a point. Just adding weight to the chassis on the LR won't work because it will upset the balance. You see adding weight to the chassis is "Sprung weight" or weight carried by the springs, which moves around during body roll and cornering, so in order to get the weight to stay in the LR it must be un-sprung weight, ie axle tubes, bird cages and suspension links. Having the rear end be heavier on the left side, on its own, helps more of the static weight stay on the LR for when you need it at corner exit. Now the reason for the heavy wheel spacers and brake rotors is two fold, one you get the added un-sprung weight for the LR, but two, you get a dampening of the engine torque and less wheel spin thru the centrifugal force, essentially legal traction control. They could've saved everyone a lot of money had they dealt with the shock/spring behind the axle back in the day and enforced the body rules and the 1 shock per wheel rule, but Pandora's box has been opened and the snakes are out. Bon Voyage.
            I may not agree with everything you say, as no one should ever agree with everything someone says, but you make really good posts. And this one is at the top.
            Up in the air who my next “favorite” driver is. Really losing hope on Bloomer getting anywhere back to “normal”.

            Comment

            • Clayton_Wetter
              Banned
              • May 2007
              • 16671

              #36
              One pound of carbide is about 2.4 times heavier than iron.

              Comment

              • Stede Bonnet
                Senior Member
                • Sep 2016
                • 325

                #37
                Originally posted by Clayton_Wetter View Post
                One pound of carbide is about 2.4 times heavier than iron.
                1 pound of steel is equal to 1 pound of carbide and both are also equal to 1 pound of aluminum in weight.
                Nobody is voluntarily putting and extra 200#....
                Politically Incorrect.

                Comment

                • Bubstr
                  Senior Member
                  • Feb 2008
                  • 3734

                  #38
                  Does anyone else see the reason the Rumley device was outlawed last year? If the rules committee wasn't smart enough last year to make a comprehensive rule that would have made this left rear rule unneeded, what makes them smart enough today. You can see by the defense, (this is what it is, like it or lump it) attitude says. They have no defense, they don't really understand it, don't want to explain it and don't want to be told about it. That is a sad way to do what is best for the sport.

                  Comment

                  • MasterSbilt_Racer
                    Senior Member
                    • May 2007
                    • 14324

                    #39
                    Originally posted by Bubstr View Post
                    Does anyone else see the reason the Rumley device was outlawed last year? If the rules committee wasn't smart enough last year to make a comprehensive rule that would have made this left rear rule unneeded, what makes them smart enough today. You can see by the defense, (this is what it is, like it or lump it) attitude says. They have no defense, they don't really understand it, don't want to explain it and don't want to be told about it. That is a sad way to do what is best for the sport.
                    Fear, caused by being overmatched, causes regretful knee-jerk reactions. We see it in all phases of life. A little investigation and understanding sure beats flailing wildly at the boogeyman.
                    Modern Day Spec Wedge Racing

                    Comment

                    • Stede Bonnet
                      Senior Member
                      • Sep 2016
                      • 325

                      #40
                      Originally posted by MasterSbilt_Racer View Post
                      Fear, caused by being overmatched, causes regretful knee-jerk reactions. We see it in all phases of life. A little investigation and understanding sure beats flailing wildly at the boogeyman.
                      Nail on head as usual.
                      Politically Incorrect.

                      Comment

                      • a25rjr
                        Senior Member
                        • Feb 2016
                        • 3774

                        #41
                        Originally posted by Centeroff
                        Stede is right about 1lb is 1lb even a pound of carbide is exactly the same weight as a pound of bread. I think what Clayton wetter meant to say was just say a 2"x2" piece of carbide would be 2.4 times heavier than a 2"x2" piece of iron.
                        Its actually 1.74 times heavier.....lead (.41lbs/cui), tungsten carbide (.70 lbs/cui).

                        However, very few use pure lead, esp if you melt lead weights from a tire shop.
                        Turn LEFT, Vote RIGHT!

                        Comment

                        • RCJ
                          Senior Member
                          • Nov 2007
                          • 509

                          #42
                          Has the minimum weight been raised to 2350 for UMP?

                          Comment

                          • Clayton_Wetter
                            Banned
                            • May 2007
                            • 16671

                            #43
                            Originally posted by Centeroff
                            Stede is right about 1lb is 1lb even a pound of carbide is exactly the same weight as a pound of bread. I think what Clayton wetter meant to say was just say a 2"x2" piece of carbide would be 2.4 times heavier than a 2"x2" piece of iron.
                            I stated that carbide is 2.4 times heavier than steel or at least that was my intent. And those are the facts.

                            Comment

                            • Stede Bonnet
                              Senior Member
                              • Sep 2016
                              • 325

                              #44
                              Originally posted by Clayton_Wetter View Post
                              I stated that carbide is 2.4 times heavier than steel or at least that was my intent. And those are the facts.
                              Your right, but some of the rule dudes are acting like these guys who've used the heavy weight exotic materials have added extra weight to their cars, above and beyond #2300, like they've all bumped up to #3200 cup cars and this added weight is in danger of breaking a now, "presumably" over loaded axle... To me this demonstrates a complete lack of understanding physics or racing on their part. The LR wheel and therefor the LR axle is still seeing roughly the same weight, +/- a few, as it would normally. They've simply traded ballast for heavy weight parts and for those of us without extravagant means to purchase exotic materials, lead is cheap to use as a substitute. If mounting was their concern they should've mandated a certain number of approved clamps and give a size and/or max weight for the mounted weight, simple. Like others have argued if they think its unsafe to mount ballast on an axle, then its unsafe to mount it to the chassis, they both see the same speeds and gyrations. My confidence in this committee and leadership is now a negative number and give me no hope for future growth or participation rates. I'm glad a few organizations here in the SE had the common sense to tell them they would NOT comply. As in the past and demonstrated by other organizations, rule makers end up doing more harm than they intend to fix because by and large they don't understand the thing they are effecting.

                              Its funny to see the advertisement to the left of this box while I'm typing still advertising the axle clamp they fear. Look I don't want to be hit by flying lead anymore than anyone else, but I've never witnessed an inspection at any race I've attended or participated in where the tech even laid a hand on or closely examined anyone's ballast or clamps. So outlawing axle weight, to me, does nothing to improve on this issue.

                              Trends come and go, and like Kevin Rumley has said in many interviews I've listen to with him, if the powers that be would've just let the trend curve continue its natural wave all would have re-balanced as technology leaked out, instead of penalizing those brave enough and creative enough to see and try new solutions to old problems. Instead they interfered when the weak minded, lazy and uncreative boo-hoo'd about somebody else being fast. We live in an age where so many believe they should be able to just buy their way to the top or conversely rewrite the rules to eliminate the experience advantage other have over them as "new racers". I actually had a gentleman tell me this week it wasn't fair to allow those with experience to be able to do things that made them quicker, he wanted new tire rules that eliminated all choice and skill so everyone was exactly equal and that I should spend 2 weeks with a new team to see how frustrating it was for them to not win right off... OMG. I told him to flip his advice on its head and he should spend 2 weeks with a veteran team and learn how to be faster and stop sniveling. I can't believe this so called, "equality" political crap has creeped into racing too. Look I'm not in favor of letting people outspend to dominate everyone, but writing rules that only further hinder those less funded is just stupid.
                              Last edited by Stede Bonnet; 02-07-2017, 09:05 AM.
                              Politically Incorrect.

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X